Top

Exploring Alternatives for the Chatbot Metaphor

Authors

Marc Steen
TNO, Den Haag, Netherlands
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7915-5459

Files

PDF Read in browser

Abstract

As ChatGPT and similar applications grow more popular, we increasingly take for granted the metaphor of the chatbot. You type. It types back. You ask questions. It gives answers. Joseph Weizenbaum warned us about what has since been known as the ELIZA effect. The conversation partner, however, is not the only possible metaphor. In this essay, four alternative metaphors are discussed: a mirror; a calculator and multiplier; a frame; and direct manipulation. The first three are used as warnings. The fourth is used to illustrate how LLM-based applications can be designed and used differently. Lastly, a proposal is made to reverse roles: to facilitate more active roles for people, so that they can cultivate virtues such as curiosity, carefulness, courage, justice, and wisdom.

PDF Read in browser

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Details